Four days of very low carbohydrate intake increased a bone-resorption marker and lowered IGF-1 in trained men—even with adequate energy intake.

doi.org

Athletes can eat enough calories and still fall short on carbohydrate. Researchers tested whether carbohydrate restriction alone—separate from an energy deficit—could alter hormones, bone turnover, and skeletal muscle in trained men.

Eight men completed two four-day diet-and-exercise conditions in randomized order. Both provided the same protein intake and maintained energy availability at 45 kilocalories per kilogram of fat-free mass per day. One diet supplied 62 percent of calories from carbohydrate; the other supplied 12 percent, replacing most of the missing carbohydrate with fat. Participants performed a standardized cycling session each day, and researchers measured blood markers, fuel use, muscle glycogen, and muscle proteins.

  • Muscle glycogen fell by 40 percent, on average, during the low-carbohydrate condition but remained stable during the normal-carbohydrate condition.
  • The low-carbohydrate diet increased fat oxidation at rest and during exercise, along with circulating free fatty acids, glycerol, and beta-hydroxybutyrate—evidence of a marked shift toward fat-based fuel use.
  • Beta-CTX, a marker of bone resorption, was higher after one, two, and four days of low carbohydrate intake. P1NP, a marker of bone formation, did not change.
  • IGF-1 decreased relative to the normal-carbohydrate condition, while insulin, testosterone, triiodothyronine, leptin, and hepcidin remained unchanged.
  • Of 671 muscle proteins analyzed, 57 responded differently between diets. Proteins involved in lipid transport and metabolism increased, while several involved in translation, muscle structure, and the extracellular matrix decreased. Contrary to the researchers' hypothesis, mitochondrial proteins did not broadly increase.

The design separated two conditions that often occur together. Low energy availability means too little dietary energy remains after exercise. Low carbohydrate availability means carbohydrate intake and stored glycogen are insufficient relative to carbohydrate use. Here, calories and protein were adequate, yet carbohydrate restriction still produced tissue-specific signals involving bone resorption and muscle anabolism.

Digest email preview

Enjoying this research? Get deeper insights like this delivered every other week.

Every other week our Premium Members receive deep dives like this alongside Rhonda's commentary and 8+ other hand-picked papers.

The findings do not show that four days of low carbohydrate intake causes osteoporosis or muscle loss. Beta-CTX and IGF-1 are biomarkers, the proteomic analysis was exploratory, and the study measured neither bone density nor muscle protein synthesis. It also included only eight trained men, lasted four days per condition, and cannot establish what happens in women, untrained people, or athletes following a lower-carbohydrate diet for months.

Still, the study challenges the idea that total calories are the only nutritional variable that matters during training. Matching carbohydrate intake to the work being performed may matter for recovery and tissue health even when overall energy intake is sufficient.

In this clip, Dr. Dominic D'Agostino discusses low-carbohydrate training, metabolic flexibility, and why athletes may restore carbohydrate availability for demanding performance.